小李飞刀

[LoneWolf]

Look out for this title, after completing 覆雨翻雲, the unknown author is going for 小李飞刀 :mrgreen:

[Hades]

Seriously anot?? I've been hoping for 小李飛刀 - 李尋歡 manga to release.. Any more detail date for this release??

[LoneWolf]

End feb, this one or two week =D>

[Hades]

yes, this is definitely another collection for me. Wonders how wells the drawings and story terms to be :?:


And finally learns my 第二式 ~ 金頂佛燈 for this 100 posts of mine :D :supz: :rock: :dance:

[LoneWolf]

This author storyline very good from his past track record but drawing is normal only but still bearable. To me, storyline come 1st :rock:

[meow]

which author har :?:
think will wait for the TW compilation :D

[Hades]

Seriously speaking, chances of having TW compilation is really low. unless they r published by Jade dynasty

[LoneWolf]

廖福成 is the author, not very well known L-) but i like his style in fact :supz:

[meow]

don't know if he will follow closely to 古龙's story line L-)

[Hades]

Hoped so since Justin said that he is good in sticking to the novels

[meow]

haha that's good news, must support liao :D
hopefully he can start on another 古龙novel 名剑风流 my fav !! :D

[LoneWolf]

Yeap, thats his previous track record :wink:

[rookiyong]

Does 廖福成 draw in Hk or China? I just flip through 覆雨翻雲 at the comic shop, not too bad.

I know a 大侠 during reservist who told me that 小李飞刀 is the best 古龙 novel, agree with that?

[Hades]

yah...小李飞刀 is the best 古龙 novel.. and also voted as the most skilful among all the characters he created in his novel

[LoneWolf]

Just got the comics 小李飛刀 - 李尋歡 yesterday, its more innovative, half the size of normal HK comics, 68pages,HK$14 so same selling price in Spore. Storywise still ok, art abit simple, overall i rate it 6.5, worth reading but collecting is hard to say :rock:

[rookiyong]

I saw it, but didnt flip through. But the cover did not print author as 廖福成?

When I see that its by 文化传信, not very keen.

[Hades]

must take a look later liao

[LoneWolf]

廖福成 gone, dunno why........ the new artist never heard before :oops:

[Hades]

Just rented this comic not long ago. Well, I can say that it is not a choice for collection.

The standard is really bad comparing to those HK weakly title.

The coloring is badly done. It will be a better choice if printed in B&W pages. Weak in battling scenes :x

I'll rate this 3 out of 10 [-X

My morale drop from 10 to 0 :x

Just wonder how long this title can be last just like the 陸小鳳 drawn by 許景深

[meow]

wah so bad.......
think i can give it a past liao :evil:

[LoneWolf]

Just rented this comic not long ago. Well, I can say that it is not a choice for collection.

The standard is really bad comparing to those HK weakly title.

The coloring is badly done. It will be a better choice if printed in B&W pages. Weak in battling scenes :x

I'll rate this 3 out of 10 [-X

My morale drop from 10 to 0 :x

Just wonder how long this title can be last just like the 陸小鳳 drawn by 許景深

You msut not be so high standard lah, take a step back, the story ok mah, else like that chinese comics no hope liao...... :((

[Hades]

Frankly speaking, it is really not up to the standard sia. The storyline is alright to me but I just can't accept the coloring. The fighting scenes can be improved though this is drawn by a new artist(probably).

Somemore, 小李飛刀 - 李尋歡 is a well known famous novel by 古龙. It's really sad to see this title gets hold by an unknown artist who handles with such disappointing standard :(

I'll follows this title for another 1-2 more issues, will decides whether I should continue following this titles anot..

[Hades]

manage to dig out this old pic

http://i3.hk.ac.sc5.yahoo.com/users/8/5/5/9/smart_lewis-img600x450-1064741602knife1.jpg

I never knows that this had been released in Yr 2000. I thinks this 1 is definitely better than the latest 1 :)

[rookiyong]

Ha, I think I have that weapon, was quite siao that time so have many items from Qiu Rui Xin's company.

Back to the comic....I think this was not the original 小李飛刀, just a replicate and it close down shortly.

Is the 小李飛刀 really so bad? I won't buy it mainly because its by 文传 :)

[LoneWolf]

I also got the yr 2000 issue spec edition.

Give this one a chance lah, author claim he will improve in his back-page note :|

Wonder where is the previous 覆雨 artist..... :(

[rookiyong]

Maybe he will take over once 覆雨 is finished. Than there is more hope for the comic :?:

I also like to support more comics, but have to be abit kind to my pocket, so choice become limited. We would have to let you keep us posted on the progress. :|

[LoneWolf]

覆雨 already finished liao just before CNY, and i anticipate him to draw this but............. :bang:

[Hades]

Is the 小李飛刀 really so bad? I won't buy it mainly because its by 文传 :)

mend for reading but definitely not for collection [-X

[kazuki]

[OT]Hey boss. Ur sig is Beyond, right? They are the king of hk rock lor... :prayer: They are the all time fav band lor [but its not appearing in ur other posts leh, no wonder i dint notice. what a waste...]
Mine is from the Land of Rising Sun. :rock: We both rock music lovers huh. :supz:

[rookiyong]

[OT]Hey boss. Ur sig is Beyond, right? They are the king of hk rock lor... :prayer: They are the all time fav band lor [but its not appearing in ur other posts leh, no wonder i dint notice. what a waste...]
Mine is from the Land of Rising Sun. :rock: We both rock music lovers huh. :supz:

[OT] just put up only, my fav band lor :prayer: [OT]

Did they mention in 小李飛 whether it will always be so small size? I find it wierd for HK weekly, maybe should have been released in 精装本, anyway I am going to flip through it today :)

[rookiyong]

Just flipped it today, not a sincere piece of work leh.

[LoneWolf]

Only 1 artist, pathetic how to good good? This guy helpless lah :((

[Hades]

No vol 2 release????

[rookiyong]

No vol 2 release????

You looking forward to it? Since they got the rights to publish the comic, should have done it well lah...cant understand why they are awarded also L-)

[Hades]

awarded as??? :?: Dun understand leh??

[rookiyong]

Cant understand why they are awarded the rights to do comic version of the novel.

[Hades]

Ic. Anyone can draws as long as they applied and permit to draw :|

[Fire]

oh?? the comic is out at the comic shop already?? wah then must go and flip flip oso.. :))

[Hades]

Vol 1 is out, vol 2 not sure as I never seen it yet

[Hades]

Just read the vol 2.

I can sees that it is slightly improving. =D>

[LoneWolf]

Really? Can keep or not? :) feel like collecting :wink:

[Hades]

Well the storyline is pretty well done. But don't expect much for the fighting scene. Nice art covers for this vol 2 which is better than the first issue. Can see much improvements this time....

Got 1 hilarious scene appears in the vol 2, quite funny =))

Justin, I thinks it will be good for u to rent it first before u really collects it.

[Fire]

wah liao...i read all you guys comment this comic till i got no mood to go flip the comic liao...is it that bad???

[Hades]

Just go and rent it for the 1st 2 vol and sees lor...

Maybe our thoughts might be different from u... Who knows??

Well, I'll still carries on following this title unless the story really goes crap in the later part :shooting:

Well, for those who still doesn't knows who the artist is, his name is known as 戰無名 (nick name).




And this is my 300 posts to learn my 第四式 ~ 佛問迦藍 :D Yupee :mrgreen:

[Fire]

who the hell is this 戰無名?? never heard before???
:?: :?: :?:

[LoneWolf]

戰無名 really never heard before but can give him chance =D>

[Hades]

The latest vol 3 is no more in small and handy size liao. It released in normal size like sheng bin, long hu men liao etc...

Should already done that when he release the 1st issues :cold: I really dislike suddenly changes on the size, should stick with it throughtout it ends.

If I happen to collects this title, I'll definitely curse the publisher upside down :yellow:

Okay, back to my topic.

Well, the cover pages for this vol is pretty well drawn. Can see lots of efforts putting in as well as improving

Still got more spaces for him to improves esp the expressions and the body which he draws :power:

[LoneWolf]

If they come out TW compilation, most probably i will buy ;)

[rookiyong]

So you Jing Guan Qi bian 1st? :scared:

[Hades]

If they come out TW compilation, most probably i will buy ;)

Chances are quite slim that there will be no compilation for this title. I can predicts that it have poor sales rate in HK.

Why would a coy publish it while they knows that it doesn't earns any profit :throw:

[LoneWolf]

Then no choice liao, definitely won't be getting it as single issue :yellow:

[meow]

wah Boss even you don't collect, the comic no chance liao :fail:

[LoneWolf]

Becos i don't like the small size and the author is really nobody.....but if it got the chance to come out the TW compilations, i will still get it :scared:

[rookiyong]

Small size maybe cant see much flaws, if big, than the comic may look "simple" :director:

[LoneWolf]

Haha you got your point ;), since Kiapheng said its improving, then must give chance lor as hardcore HK comics supporter :hello:

[Hades]

Like I say earlier, collection is not a best choice, just rent it and browse through lor :power:

[LoneWolf]

In my whole life, i never rent a comics becos i hate seeing comics torn and old......i hurt me so i always buy and keep. haha stupid mentality right :(

[Hades]

I also seldom rent comics till I gives out collecting feng yun and sells them to my fren. I rents the HK weekly comics after that. For jap wise, I seldom rents them except for a few titles.

[rookiyong]

In my whole life, i never rent a comics becos i hate seeing comics torn and old......i hurt me so i always buy and keep. haha stupid mentality right :(

Same for me. So those I dun want to read, I will not even rent. Limited exposure for me.

[Fire]

well for me...the hk comic too many title to collect laio...so i use to rent and read on spot. for jap comics, i never rent...always buy...selected titles only...i very fussy on collecting comics.... :fail:

[Hades]

likewise for me. Only those selected titles will get esp works by those famous artists like 北條司, 井上雄彥, 車田正美, 三條陸 etc..

[rookiyong]

You notice that this is the topic with the most replies so far.

Morale of the story: Either you come out with something very good, or come out with something bad....and ppl will pay attention to it.

just a joke :read:

[Hades]

Through =)) So u finally changed the font size =D>

[Hades]

It seems like it had been stopped releasing since last week.. Anyone seen the vol 5 in the comic shop?

[LoneWolf]

The comics didn't even bring it in :(